Wednesday, September 29, 2010

PIGNUS

Contract

PIGNUS

Object

Guarantee of a debit/ Pledge

Definition

Pignus was a contract in which a debtor delivered a thing to his creditor as security for the debt. The delivery of the thing gave rise to the obligation on the part of the debtor to return it upon payment of the debt.

Type of contract

Real – perfected by the delivery of the thing-, bonae fidei

Parties

Pledgor (debtor)    

in this contract both parties were benefitted

Pledgee (creditor)

Obligations

Pledgee: to return the thing upon payment – in case he excercised the right of sale if the debt was not paid, he had to return the balance of the proceeds after paying himself the amount of the debt)


 

Pledgor: expenses caused by the thing to the pledgee

Features

There were three kinds of pignus in Roman Law:

  • Pignus: Mobile objects- the pledge has material possession of the thing
  • Hypotheca: it is similar to the modern mortgage – no material transfer of the thing
  • Antichresis

Essential Elements

Credit

Delivery of the Object

Ownership of the object (if something was given in pignus, it could be sold in case of default of payment. If a third party allowed a thing to be pignus of someone else's credir, he was guaranteeing the other person's credit himself)

Standard of care

Because both parties benefitted the standard of care is Omnia diligentia (culpa levis- bonus pater familiae- objective standard)

Action

Pledgee: Actio pignoraticia directa

Pledgor: Actio pignoraticia contraria

Tuesday, September 28, 2010

DEPOSITUM

Contract

DEPOSITUM

Object    

Safekeeping/Custody of things

Definition

Depositum in a contract by which one person (depositor) delivered a thing to another one (depositee/ depositaruim) to keep for him gratuitously and to return it on demand

Type of contract

Bilateral, Bonae fidei, real – perfected by the delivery of the thing-

Parties

Depositor: Beneficiary of this contract

Depositee/ depositarium

Obligations

Depositee: To keep the thing delivered and return exactly what he has received on demand

Features

Ownership is not transferred –difference with mutuum

Use is not allowed- difference with commodatum

Essential Elements

Delivery of the thing

Irregular deposit: when fungible things or consumable things (like money) were delivered in deposit (for safekeeping purposes) it was considered an irregular deposit ( in reality is a mutuum but it was allowed as an irregular deposit to allow the action depositum which was bonae fideii instead of the Actio Condictio which was of strict law)- THINK ABOUT THE MONEY YOU PUT IN THE BANKS

Standard of care

Depositee/Depositarium: was only liable for dolus , loss or damage caused by positive action from him

Depositor: expenses and damages caused by the thing

Action

Breach of depositee: fail to return the thing on demand: Actio depositum directa

To enforce rights from this contract against the depositor: Actio depositum contraria

MUTUUM

Contract Name

MUTUUM

Object

Loan of consumption

Definition

There will be mutuum or consumption loan, when a party is obliged to deliver a number of things to another party that the latter is allowed to consume or exchange. The receiving party must return in the agreed time, as many things of the same kind and quality. The thing under this contract must be consumable or fungible when not consumable

Parties

Lender

Borrower: he is the beneficiary of this contract UNLESS the parties agree on interests

Type of contract

Gratuit (Onerous onlyif there are interests agreed), real –perfected by the traditio-, stricti iuris

Obligation

Borrower: To return equivalent + agreed interest

Features

Compound interest (to charge interest over interests owed): Prohibited

Usury limit: 1/12 per year in XII tables – reduce to 1/24 per year. Justinian: 4 to 12% depending on the person

Essential Elements

  1. Traditio
  2. Object: Mobile, fungible or consumable.
  3. Determined: Quantity, quality and type

Standard of care

Borrower was the owner of the thing after it had been handed over.

Remedies

Condictio